A primary care study in France found that more than two thirds of patients with negative chest x-rays were prescribed antibiotics for community-acquired pneumonia (CAP), researchers reported yesterday in the Annals of Family Medicine.
The prospective cross-sectional study, conducted from November 2017 through December 2019, included adults with clinically suspected CAP who had received chest radiography (CR) as part of their evaluation. While French guidelines require a positive CR result for diagnosis of CAP, they don't specify the course of action when a patient with clinically suspected CAP has a negative chest x-ray. The aim of the study was to determine how CR results effect general practitioners' decision to initiate antibiotics for suspected CAP.
"Beyond the presumed necessity of CR and the possibility in daily practice of performing CR without delay, it is important to analyze antibiotic initiation by general practitioners (GPs) for suspected CAP according to CR results," researchers from Universite Paris Cite and Universite Sorbonne Paris Nord wrote.
Negative CR has low impact on antibiotic initiation decision
Of the 259 patients (median age, 58 years) in the study, 144 (55.6%) had a positive CR. Antibiotics were initiated for 142/143 (99.3%) patients with positive CR and 79/115 (68.7%) with negative CR. Patients with positive CR results had higher body temperature, faster heart rate, faster breathing rate, more difficulty breathing, more frequent unilateral chest pain, and longer-lasting symptoms than patients with negative CR results.
The researchers also note that among the CR-negative patients, there wasn't much difference in clinical symptoms between those who received antibiotics and those who didn't.
"The effect of a negative CR on the antibiotic initiation decision appears to be low," the researchers concluded. "This raises questions regarding the role of CR in the management strategy for CAP and justifies clarification of the guidelines as to what should be done in case of clinical suspicion of CAP without radiologic confirmation."