Implementation of an ambulatory antibiotic stewardship program (ASP) intervention at a network of hospitals and clinics cut unnecessary antibiotic prescribing for upper respiratory infections (URIs) by 50% without diminishing patient satisfaction, researchers reported today in Infection Control & Hospital Epidemiology.
The multifaceted ambulatory ASP intervention, implemented across Mayo Clinic facilities in Minnesota, Wisconsin, Arizona, and Florida in July 2020, aimed to reduce antibiotic use for tier 3 URI syndromes, which are defined as URIs for which antibiotics should never be prescribed. In a study published in 2023, Mayo Clinic researchers reported the intervention was associated with 48.4% relative reduction in the antibiotic prescribing rate for tier 3 URI encounters.
In this study, Mayo Clinic researchers analyzed data from patients who completed surveys with six questions assessing patient satisfaction pre- and post-implementation. Participants in both cohorts were aged 19 to 65 years, predominantly female, and had received care from either a physician or an advanced practice provider.
No difference in patient satisfaction
Overall, a total of 75,874 tier 3 primary care encounters occurred during the pre- and post-implementation periods. Among the 2,956 survey participants (1,715 from the pre- and 1,241 from the post-implementation cohorts), tier 3 antibiotic prescribing decreased from 28.3% pre- to 14.1% post-implementation (a 50% relative reduction).
When the researchers compared the survey responses of the pre- versus post-implementation cohorts, they found no statistically significant changes for any of the six survey questions or their associated means. For the first question ("Likelihood of you recommending our practice to others"), antibiotic prescribing was associated with statistically significant higher mean satisfaction scores in the overall and pre-implementation cohorts, but the researchers say the difference in mean score was small and may not be meaningfully different.
The researchers say that while the survey respondents represent only a small subset of the overall tier 3 encounters during the study, and the responses may skew toward patients with stronger opinions, the findings are still noteworthy.
"Programmatic efforts to reduce inappropriate antibiotic prescribing should not be dissuaded by concerns over reduced patient satisfaction, although empowering providers with tools to educate patients and provide non-antibiotic value are paramount," they concluded.